(A column in the author’s “Tangled Bank” series for Orion magazine, having to do with taking a long view of ecological processes and perception. Published Sept/Oct 2004.)


In the dim deepwood of massive and moss-bound trees, the three tenors of the Northwest forest give voice: varied thrush’s raspy note, like whistling through spit; golden-crowned kinglets’ high tinkle, the sound older ears lose first; and winter wrens, pucks with pennywhistles on an endless tape loop. A fourth, pileated woodpecker, is silent for now, having already totemed all the big old snags.

I’ve come to a place known as the Log Decomposition Plot. The mossy turnoff is paved in evergreen violets. Then comes a trench and berm to keep vehicles out, but the bulldozed tank-trap has grown to resemble a native outcrop, covered in sword fern, salal, and moss. Fresh windthrow renders the trail almost impassable in places: a suitable gateway to a place where, when a tree falls in the forest, a lot of people hear it–and then take a close look at what happens next.

When I get to the laid-out logs and the sawed-off tree-rounds that fallers call cookies, I know I’ve arrived in the place where druids of forest research make offerings to Rot. This is the H. J. Andrews Experimental Forest, 16,000 acres situated deep in the Cascade Mountains, managed by Oregon State University and the U. S. Forest Service. The Andrews, dedicated to forest research since 1948, became a charter member of the National Science Foundation’s Long-Term Ecological Research Program in 1980. Funda-mental study of the northern spotted owl took place here, along with much basic research on forest function. Recently, recognizing that science is not the only tool for probing what forests mean, the Forest Service and the Spring Creek Project of OSU’s Philosophy Department initiated a program of Long-Term Ecological Reflection. This inspired whim is the source of my good luck in spending a week here, reflecting and writing.

Whole watersheds of old growth western hemlock and Douglas-fir, simply shocking compared to the second- and third-growth evergreens of my home hills, grace the HJA. The Decomposition Plot, devoted to studies of nutrient cycling and forest refreshment, lies in one such ancient stand. It’s easy to tell when I’m inside the research zone by the yellow, red, and blue tags on wire stems sprouting from the moss. One pink cluster pokes like old trilliums from a mossy mound that once was a tree. A red bunch limns the ground where a one-time log has finally given up the ghost. Metal tags label the cut butt-ends of many logs that lie about higgledy piggledy, as gravity and the wind might have arranged them had researchers not dropped them first. Bright flags beribbon trees, shrubs, small boles, and limbs, and duct tape shores up the ends of some logs: is someone investigating the degradation rate of duct tape as well as wood fiber? White plastic pipes, buckets, jugs, and other bits lie here and there, each significant to some experiment or other. In early spring, no one is here for me to ask.

Some would see all these artifacts as litter, marring their wilderness experience. You can also see them as inflorescences, like that mysterious white plastic funnel sprouting next to a nodding trillium. Take away the pink ribbon around that hemlock over there, pick up all the aluminum and plastic, and this old growth forest would still work just like any other. Researchers cut fresh cookies for a starting point, then measure their decay forever after–or, at least, as long as they can. But let all the straight-cuts rot away, and you’ve got an untidy place going about its important business of trading in the old for the new; an ecosystem definitely in it for the long haul.

Most of us take the short-term view, most of the time. What gratifies right now, or soon at the latest, is always more compelling than what might satisfy years from now, let alone nourish the generations. When business opts for short-term profits instead of long-term husbandry, both forest and human communities suffer. The short view is what turned most of the Northwest’s giant forests into doghair conifer plantations cut on short rotation for pulp. To peer much further down the line requires not only empathy for those who follow, but also faith in the future–even if you won’t be there to see it for yourself. Such an ethic underlies all of the long-term studies here on the Andrews, whether concerned with old-growth ecology, hydrology, riparian restoration, forest development and mortality, carbon dynamics, invertebrate diversity, or climate change and its effects.

Meanwhile, here in the decomp plot, nuthatches toot in monolithic columns of Douglas-fir; a robin chitters in a clearing. Dappled light falls on forests of the moss called Hylocomium splendens, hammocks of shiny twinflower leaves, and fleshy Lobaria lichens lying about like tossed-up ocean foam. The path is a maze of Irish byways for voles. Douglas squirrels leave their middens of Douglas-fir cone bracts all about like a prodigal’s spent treasures, and round leaves of evergreen violets and wild ginger spatter the path like green coins. If they were gold, I doubt they’d distract the unseen leprechauns who come here to gather the data of decline. Gold doesn’t decompose, and this place is all about the documentation of rot. It goes on all around me: something fairly large just fell from a nearby old-growth giant.

Maybe that’s the problem with the long view: it speaks of our own inevitable demise. We’re not much into self-recycling. Even in death, we take heroic steps to forestall rot by boxing our leavings in expensive, hermetic containers. After all, to anticipate the future–a future without us–is asking quite a lot. But life and regeneration are the name of the game on this mortal plane, every bit as much as corruption. The winter wren’s song, after all, is no morbid message. Old vine maples hoop and droop under their epiphytic shawls, but the unfurling leaves of the young ones are the brightest items in the forest (even brighter than the red plastic tags). Every downed and decaying cylinder of cellulose makes yards of nitrogen-rich surface area for hopeful baby hemlocks, lichens, liverworts, and entire empires of moss to GRASP and begin making forest anew.

If we care about what comes next, it makes sense to send delegates to the present to find out how things truly are, report back, and check in again year after year. The conundrum of the diminishing baseline says that if we have no clear idea of what went before, we are more likely to accept things as we find them, no matter how degraded they may be. Memory is short, the collective memory even shorter. But with baseline in hand, when change comes, we can appreciate it for what it is. Recognizing loss, we may even act to prevent future loss.

Just as the scientists gather data, any open-eyed observer could go on documenting details without end in such a place: the declination of that row of saplings bent over one deadfall by another; the way that one sword fern catches the sun to suggest a helmet; how the polypore conks launch out from cut ends as soon as they can after their vertical hosts go horizontal, their mycelia re-orienting ninety degrees to the zenith. There is no end to particulars as long as the forest goes on and there is someone to record them. Or not. The moss grows, the raven barks, the trees go to soil–first hemlocks, then firs, finally cedar. All the while, the decomp team is there, watching how the cookies crumble. Maybe looking to the future is a way of hoping there will still be something to see when we get there. Maybe it’s the only way to make sure of it.

Robert Michael Pyle PDFs:

Writings from the HJ Andrews

Orion: The Long Haul


Robert Michael Pyle is a lepidopterist, and a professional writer who has published twelve books and hundreds of papers, essays, stories and poems. He has a Ph.D. from the School of Forestry and Environmental Studies at Yale University. His acclaimed 1987 book Wintergreen describing the devastation caused by unrestrained logging in Washington’s Willapa Hills near his adopted home was the winner of the 1987 John Burroughs Medal for Distinguished Nature Writing. His books include Where Bigfoot Walks: Crossing the Dark Divide,Wintergreen: Rambles in a Ravaged Land, and Sky Time in Gray’s River: Living for Keeps in a Forgotten Place. He won the 2007 National Outdoor Book Award.